Comparison

2022 Mercedes-Benz C-Class vs BMW Three Collection vs Volvo S60 vs Audi A4 Comparability Assessment: Government Resolution

Written by Gulati

Premium govt sedans have come a great distance. It began out as inexpensive automobiles which had been then modified to be barely fancier and have extra luxurious. In an age of high-riding SUVs, the three-box automobile has created a distinct segment for itself, particularly in India the place you might be undeniably spoilt for decisions.  You’ve got the BMW Three Collection which is extra sport-inclined, the A4 from the model with the 4 rings for its pleasing driving expertise, and the S60 is synonyms with its excessive security requirements. Then there’s additionally the brand new C-Class, which is undoubtedly Mercedes-Benz’s most necessary mannequin within the nation. Now, in case you have about Rs. 50 lakh to spend on certainly one of these premium govt sedans, then which one ought to it’s? Properly, that is precisely why we’re right here in the present day that can assist you make this resolution.

[embedded content]

Exterior

A fantastic premium govt sedan should be each luxurious and sporty to not point out it should be handsome. The Volvo S60 impresses us with its quintessential European look that’s each refined and trendy. A lovely hood, the familial Volvo grille, glossy LED headlights, and Volvo’s signature Thor’s hammer LED DRLs, what’s to not like? The C-Class with its edgy and aggressive face, sharper bumper, and that stimulating star-studded entrance grille, maintains a mode that chauffeured house owners cannot ignore.

A fantastic premium govt sedan should be each luxurious and sporty to not point out it should be handsome.
Photograph Credit score: Apoorv Choudhary

The A4 is similar previous fifth-gen mannequin beneath however would not come off as outdated. Its brawnier nostril, angrier eyes, and a number of creases on its physique make it very putting.  And if you need a sports activities sedan in its truest kind, then the 330Li M Sport will fulfill your proverbial style buds. It’s aggressive but engaging and is the longest within the section but exudes that posh saloon feels.

287rigs8

Design is, after all, subjective, and plenty of would have their very own valuations. 
Photograph Credit score: Apoorv Choudhary

Now, design is, after all, subjective, and plenty of have their very own valuations however all these automobiles, no matter the badges look splendid within the rear-view mirror however for us, it is the S60 that has our hearts pulsating.

2qkkqvbg

For us, it is the Volvo S60 that has our hearts pulsating.
Photograph Credit score: Apoorv Choudhary

Tech & Inside

Whereas talking of Rs. 50 lakh automobiles it’s totally necessary to be as stunning and swanky on the skin as on the within and all these automobiles are a illustration of simply that. The cockpit of the S60 leaves an enduring imprint. The White and Beige theme is properly finished, the match and end are top-notch, and the 9-inch Sensus touchscreen is crisp, responsive, and controls all of the options contained in the cabin. However isn’t probably the most handy to make use of whereas driving. The white Nappa Leather-based upholstery appears to be like stunning however could possibly be troublesome to take care of. The entrance seats are wonderful providing unparalleled coziness.

j5ek6aio

Whereas talking of Rs. 50 lakh automobiles it’s totally necessary to be as stunning and swanky on the skin as on the within and all these automobiles are a illustration of simply that.
Photograph Credit score: Apoorv Choudhary

The cabin of the C-Class is all about luxurious. The brand new era mannequin will get a brand new Avant-Garde format. The whole lot is knitted for sophistication. The 11.9-inch vertical centre display screen is beneficiant and homes all in-car controls. The 12.3-inch instrument panel is fancy and customisable. The steering touch-pad controls are flush and work nicely with a flick of a finger. The supplies used look fabulous. Upholstery may be very wealthy, however seats miss out on air flow.

nvhr7t4

All automobiles get an electrical sunroof, however we had been impressed with the glass panes on the 3GL (top-left) and the C-Class (backside proper).
Photograph Credit score: Apoorv Choudhary

The cabin of the A4 may not excite you and a few may even really feel that it’s the least spectacular. However there are a number of notable parts. The 10.1-inch touchscreen nonetheless appears to be like recent. Really feel may be very perceptible, and really straightforward to make use of. It will get Apple CarPlay and Android Auto. In contrast to the S60 and the C-Class, the temperature right here is managed through a rotary knob. Different creature comforts are additionally button oriented. However the A4 is equally premium consistent with what you count on from a automotive on this section.

25sssduo

The BMW 330Li M Sport (top-left) has the largest boot within the section. 
Photograph Credit score: Apoorv Choudhary

The cabin of the three Collection Gran Limousine M Sport may be very nicely completed. Ambient lighting on the rear door trim is a pleasant contact. The newest era of the BMW iDrive 7.Zero interface works nicely on the 12.3-inch touchscreen. Materials high quality is admirable with the sensible utilization of plastic, leather-based, and steel. The rear AC vents with straightforward controls would make anybody on the again completely happy! You additionally get wi-fi Android Auto and Apple CarPlay and a 360-degree digital camera. Fairly tech-laden!

1g1jabk

Ambient lighting on the 2022 Mercedes-Benz C200 is the very best within the section. 
Photograph Credit score: Apoorv Choudhary

Rear Seat Area

However most prospects would choose to be pushed in these automobiles moderately than drive them for probably the most a part of the day that’s.

Dimension Volvo S60 T4 Inscription Mercedes-Benz C200 BMW 330Li M Sport Audi A4 Know-how
Size 4,761 mm 4,751 mm 4,819 mm 4,762 mm
Width 2,040 mm 2,033 mm 2,068 mm 2,022 mm
Peak 1,431 mm 1,437 mm 1,441 mm 1,433 mm
Wheelbase 2,872 mm 2,865 mm 2,961 mm 2,819 mm
Boot Area 442-litre 455-litre 480-litre 460-litre

If rear house consolation is your precedence, look no additional than the three GL. The rear doorways are 110 mm longer than the common Three Collection means getting out and in is simple. Because of its stretched footprint, the 3GL has a extra spacious again seat than the remaining. The legroom is ample, the headrest and central armrest make issues comfy, and 480-litre of boot house isn’t a compromise.

qdishtp

If rear house consolation is your precedence, look no additional than the BMW 330Li M Sport (prime left).
Photograph Credit score: Apoorv Choudhary

The opposite three are undoubtedly spacious, get computerized local weather management, particular person charging ports, and the works, however the 3GL is a bang for the buck.

Engine/ Gearbox

We drove all of the automobiles back-to-back and had been happy with the number of drives every automotive provided.

Mannequin Volvo S60 T4 Inscription Mercedes-Benz C200 BMW 330Li M Sport Audi A4 Know-how  
Displacement 1,969 cc 1,496 cc 1,998 cc 1,984 cc  
Gas Petrol Petrol Petrol Petrol  
Energy 188 bhp @5,000 rpm 201 bhp @ 5,800 rpm 255 bhp @5,000 rpm 188 bhp @4,200 rpm  
Torque 300 Nm @1,700 – 4,000 rpm 300 Nm @1,800 – 4,000 rpm 400 Nm @1,550 – 4,400 rpm 320 Nm @1,450 – 4,200 rpm  
Transmission 8-Pace Automated 9-Pace Automated 8-Pace Automated 7-Pace DCT  
Drive sort Entrance-Wheel Drive Rear-wheel drive Rear-Wheel Drive Entrance-Wheel Drive  

The A4 is powered by a 2.0-litre 40 TFSI unit growing 188 bhp and 320 Nm. Now, this unit might really feel low on energy however that does not make the automotive sluggish. After all, it is no rocket ship however it will not slack behind both. Regardless of the preliminary bottom-end lag, the A4 is fast. Engine refinement is spectacular and the quick-shifting DCT may be very alert. Below arduous acceleration although, you may end up asking for extra. However in comes the paddle shifters to your rescue and make the drive pleasing.

njgl029g

The BMW 330Li M Sport is probably the most authoritative and the quickest automotive right here.
Photograph Credit score: Apoorv Choudhary

Volvo’s 2.0-litre engine is probably the most relaxed on this section. It has the identical output because the A4 however not like the Audi energy supply right here is extra linear with hardly any sense of urgency. Which isn’t in any respect dangerous however will not fulfill the fanatic inside you. The 8-speed torque converter is easy shifting and prioritises consolation.

The C200 has the smallest unit on this section however packs in sufficient punch, much more than the S60 and the A4. The low-end torque is noticeable and is sort of up for the job no matter what you throw at it. It’s going to maintain as much as various speeds nicely and excursions simply as fortunately because it commutes, the mild-hybrid system additionally has an enormous function to play right here. The 9-speed computerized is superb and is flawless in Regular Mode. In order for you extra from the engine, then swap to both Sport or Sport+ drive modes. The C200 is easy, quiet, comfy, and simple. Simply the best way it needs to be.

954ri5vo

The BMW 330Li M Sport’s (prime left) 8-speed torque converter is a thoughts reader and at all times retains you in the correct gear.
Photograph Credit score: Apoorv Choudhary

The second you speed up the 3GL M Sport, you understand, it is sport on. With 255 bhp and 400 Nm of torque from its 2.0-litre turbo petrol motor, the 3GL is probably the most authoritative and the quickest automotive right here. The four-cylinder unit is free-revving and provides a scorching efficiency. To not point out, that the refinement ranges are class-leading, and the shifts are silky easy. In Sport mode, the throttle response turns into sharper, and the gearbox turns into extra alert. Not that it is essentially wanted as a result of the three’s 8-speed torque converter, is a thoughts reader and at all times retains you in the correct gear. It doesn’t matter what!

Gas Effectivity

And if effectivity is what you are searching for, then the A4 will impress you with its claimed determine of 17.42 kmpl intently adopted by the newest C200 due to the 48V gentle hybrid system. Volvo’s S60 is the least environment friendly petrol providing on this section, whereas the BMW is not fairly the drinker you’ll take it to be.

Volvo S60 T4 Inscription Mercedes-Benz C200 BMW 330Li M Sport Audi A4 Know-how  
14.08 kmpl 16.9 kmpl 15.Three kmpl 17.42 kmpl  

Experience & Dealing with

The Volvo S60 sits on a agency suspension however that does not translate into an thrilling expertise. Its corner-carving abilities aren’t top-notch and if pushed arduous then the large 1,700 kg machine shows fairly a little bit of physique roll. There’s an evident vibration felt throughout the cabin at low speeds, one thing you will not admire from the rear seats however shortly settles down as soon as the automotive picks up velocity.

gkimrrgg

There’s an evident vibration felt throughout the cabin of the Volvo S60 at low speeds, one thing you will not admire from the rear seats. 
Photograph Credit score: Apoorv Choudhary

The Audi A4 has a pointy distinction in its dealing with in comparison with the S60. Steering is extra direct and even turns shortly, be it in visitors or on corners. Physique roll is negligible and can at all times encourage you with its nimble and supple trip high quality. Be it from the entrance or on the rear.

amhpb8ko

Steering is extra direct on the Audi A4 and even turns shortly, be it in visitors or on corners.
Photograph Credit score: Apoorv Choudhary

The Mercedes-Benz C-Class might be probably the most sorted automotive on this section. It has phenomenal management over undulating roads. Steering is fast, direct and in tighter corners, it hurls itself with poise. And the rear-wheel-drive set-up helps you take pleasure in corners much more. However higher brakes would’ve additional enhanced that have.

v8i303a8

The Mercedes-Benz C-Class might be probably the most sorted automotive on this section.
Photograph Credit score: Apoorv Choudhary

Leaving everybody behind is the 3GL, once more, with its sharp steering, exact dealing with on corners and the rear-wheel-drive set-up solely makes it pleasing. To not point out the grin it leaves on you for the remainder of the day.

gr43roj8

BMW 330Li M Sport with its sharp steering, exact dealing with on corners, and the rear-wheel-drive set-up makes the drive pleasing.
Photograph Credit score: Apoorv Choudhary

Verdict

Now, for the all-important govt resolution. All of the automobiles are a dominating pressure. So, choosing one was at all times going to be arduous. However for the sake of being goal, let’s wind again shortly. When it comes to design, the reply is simple, it’s the Volvo S60 for us. In total cabin really feel, though all of the automobiles are equally luxurious, supply ample house, and are loaded with tech, we really feel each the C-Class and the three Collection GL M Sport are worthy of this honour. When it comes to total engine refinement, gearbox response, trip & dealing with; there is not any more sensible choice than the three GL. However all the things boils right down to the pricing.

s02i0a2g

The Audi A4 and the Volvo S60 are each nice merchandise, little doubt.
Photograph Credit score: Apoorv Choudhary

Mannequin Volvo S60 Mercedes-Benz C-Class BMW Three Collection GL Audi A4
Costs (ex-showroom) Rs. 45.90 lakh Rs. 55 lakh- Rs. 61 lakh Rs. 54.50 lakh- Rs. 56.90 lakh Rs. 40.49 lakh- Rs. 48.99 lakh

The Audi A4 and the Volvo S60 are each nice merchandise, little doubt. The S60 is available in a single petrol variant whereas the A4 has a base Premium trim which is equally knitted and a totally loaded, top-spec Know-how trim however they do not tick all of the bins for a buyer who’s most likely entering into the luxurious house for the very first time. And so, it actually comes down to those two- the three GL and the C200. On one facet, you’ve got the proper driver’s automotive, it is probably the most spacious, most partaking, and combines sportiness and luxurious masterfully. You additionally get a diesel to select from which is intently priced to its petrol sibling.

enjcocf

The BMW 330 Li M Sport is the proper driver’s automotive, is probably the most spacious, most partaking, and combines sportiness and luxurious masterfully. 
Photograph Credit score: Apoorv Choudhary

Alternatively, we have now the newest C-Class. It has all the things that you’d need from a brand new automotive and can even stand out if you drive into your high-rise house and even if you step out for a social outing. However all the things that you just want is concentrated on the entrance not notably useful should you can be chauffeured round. It is a well-rounded product little doubt, however the excessive price ticket it carries would not actually justify what it provides. And that is the place the 3GL makes a case for itself and rightly so, wins this showdown of the chief class!

About the author

Gulati