What defines a contemporary three-row SUV! Properly the mantra is straightforward. One thing which is a snug household mover with sufficient house for six or seven, can deal with difficult terrains with ease and feels ‘premium’! And that is precisely what we’ve got at present. In truth, not one however three of them, however the query is, which is the higher one?
The Mahindra XUV700 has been the speak of the city and the 70,000 bookings that it acquired on the blink of an eye fixed very nicely substantiates that. However here is the place the true check of this SUV lies because it will get pitted in opposition to a few of its well-established rivals just like the Hyundai Alcazar and the Tata Safari. Then there’s even the MG Hector Plus which too is a three-row model of the Hector and is offered in the identical six or seven seater structure. However sadly MG isn’t in a position to present us with a check automobile but.
Very apparently, all these SUVs are very completely different to take a look at. Whereas the XUV700 has a really up to date and sharp, the opposite two positively have that household face flavour and are impressed by their respective compact SUV derivatives. Tata Safari builds up on Harrier’s design and positively appears very well-rounded, city and but has the butch attraction of an SUV. Even the Hyundai Alcazar alternatively has that Creta sense very a lot intact however appears extra subtle and MPVish. The Mahindra XUV700 alternatively is the showstopper. It appears hanging and that brawny sense of an SUV may be very interesting. Sure! The entrance finish appears a bit overdone particularly with these floating DRLs, nevertheless it’s nonetheless charming and will get you all the eye.
|Dimensions||Mahindra XUV700||Tata Safari||Hyundai Alcazar|
|Size||4695 mm||4661 mm||4500 mm|
|Width||1890 mm||1894 mm||1790 mm|
|Top||1755 mm||1786 mm||1675 mm|
|Wheelbase||2750 mm||2741 mm||2760 mm|
Having stated that, all three of them surprisingly are very completely different relating to dimensions.The XUV is the longest of the lot whereas the Tata Safari is the widest. But it surely’s Hyundai Alcazar with the longest wheelbase. Let’s have a look at how that displays on the within.
Properly on the within, all three SUVs have their hits and misses and we start with the oldest of the lot.
Inside & Tech
Alright, so the very first thing that you just discover is that you just get a very excessive seating place, which provides you a commanding view out of the windscreen and the steering is actually good actually chunky to carry. And aside from that, so far as infotainment is anxious, you could have the 8.8-inch touchscreen and naturally, it additionally will get Apple CarPlay and Android Auto and aside from that you’ve got these drive modes right here. The up to date mannequin that Tata launched after the launch of the Safari, and in that up to date mannequin, you additionally get wi-fi charging and ventilated seats.
The second-row scores excessive on consolation and practicality. The seat will be slid ahead to make room for the third-row passengers and even the entrance passenger seat will be adjusted from the second-row to make extra legroom for the boss seat. After which there’s a 60:40 cut up, centre armrest with two cupholders, AC vents and the sunroof is sort of huge to offer you that extra ethereal really feel. You do sit a bit knees up within the third-row however the house is definitely good for shorter commutes. For options you could have air-con vents right here, charging ports and likewise devoted space for storing on your cellphone.
And now we come to the Hyundai Alcazar. Properly, the Alcazar immediately feels a bit too compact and you are not in the perfect place and find yourself feeling fairly cramped. The house isn’t too good for an grownup of my dimension and is greatest beneficial for youths. For options, there are air-con vents, two USB ports on either side, cupholders and place to maintain your cellular. However the second-row is little bit of a mixed-bag. You possibly can slide ahead or again the seats and even recline them. And these are captain seats, which is also an possibility on the Safari as nicely, however these are usually not as huge as those that we noticed on safari. The seats on the Tata Safari affords higher thigh assist than these on the Alcazar. They’re comfy however below thigh assist might have been even higher, When it comes to options, there’s wi-fi charger within the second-row which is a segment-first. There are AC vents, USB charging level and likewise a cellphone holder. After which you could have some space for storing like this tray holder that may carry as much as 3.5 kgs of load. And eventually I get these sunblinds as nicely, once more a segment-first.
Right here within the driver’s seat the very first thing that you just discover is the two-tone upholstery. The cabin appears and feels very premium and you’ve got a glossy 10.25-inch touchscreen infotainment system. Once more Apple CarPlay, Android Auto and related automobile know-how are onboard and also you get a premium Bose sound system as nicely. The Tata Safari will get a JBL Harman sound system and the Mahindra XUV7OO has a Sony Sound System. Then you definately even have ventilated seats with three ranges, wi-fi charging as nicely.
And eventually we’re within the second row of the XUV700 and much like the Safari, It feels very comfy within the second row. The thigh assist is sweet and also you do get AC vents, centre armrest and 60:40 format for the seats to recline them. However a significant downside right here is that you just can’t slide them ahead to create more room within the third-row. However can nonetheless slide ahead the entrance passenger seat by doing one thing much like what we did on the Safari. So far as options go, it will get a Sort C charging level and a small cellphone holder as nicely. To not point out, the Piano black therapy and wood end on the doorways is one thing good and has a premium contact. And Sure! You do get fairly a giant sunroof and when you do get a really feel of that within the third-row, the kneeroom is simply marginally higher than the Alcazar. You continue to sit knees up and the house is cramped. It is even brief on headroom and also you continually concern about bumping your head on the roof. So once more, this place is greatest suited to children within the household. Even when it comes to options there’s only a single 12 volt charger right here whereas in different two vehicles we’ve got USB ports. You additionally get only one cupholder and there is no house to maintain your cellphone.
Coming to the first-row, it does miss out on ventilated seats and that is a giant miss as a result of the opposite two vehicles get within the top-spec fashions a minimum of. And of-course this together with the Hyundai Alcazar will get blind spot monitor. So, the second you turn on the indicator in the direction of the left or the precise, you could have a small show right here on the instrument console which exhibits the site visitors coming from behind you. Other than that you’ve got this Mercedes styled you realize twin screens on the dashboard. It offers the sprint actually premium and refined look and although this color appears good. However in Indian dusty situations, sustaining it going to be a troublesome bit. When it comes to connectivity, Sure! This comes with Mahindra, a dream traces connectivity know-how. You even have apple carplay android auto, and it has wi-fi charging. After which, the top-spec luxury-line Mahindra XUV700 AX7L with us additionally comes with the superior driver help system or ADAS, bringing in additional driver help options like ahead collisions warning, cross-traffic alert and lane change alert amongst others.
Efficiency And Dynamics
So we’ve got informed you all in regards to the options and the consolation that Tata Safari affords and it is now time to get behind the wheel. The Tata Safari will get the tried and examined fiat-sourced 2.0-litre, four-cylinder Kryotec diesel engine that belts out 168 bhp at 3750 rpm and 350 Nm at 1750 – 2500 rpm. The oil-burner is mated to both a six-speed guide gearbox or a Hyundai-sourced six-speed torque-converter computerized transmission. With us is the automated.
|Max Energy||168 bhp @ 3750 rpm|
|Peak Torque||350 Nm @ 1750 – 2500 rpm|
|Transmission||6-Velocity MT / 6-Velocity AT|
And when you speak in regards to the driving dynamics of the automobile, the dealing with specifically. So this specific automobile, it is a media automobile, and I really feel I sense that there’s some quantity of play within the steering. The steering itself isn’t very, you realize, suggestions oriented, it’s mild. It does weigh up at greater speeds, however the total sense of confidence that you just get when driving the automobile. And so far as braking is anxious, the brakes on the Safari are fairly satisfactory and a bit extra chunk would have been reassuring. One factor that has impressed probably the most on this automobile has been the journey high quality after all that stands out and is likely one of the highlights on this automobile. Even within the third-row the precise high quality is sweet, the lateral motion you do not really feel it that a lot right here and even for the house so I am comfy for shorter commutes.
|Hyundai Alcazar||2.0-litre Petrol||1.5-litre Diesel|
|Displacement||1999 cc||1493 cc|
|Max Energy||157 bhp @ 6500 rpm||113 bhp @ 4000 rpm|
|Peak Torque||191 Nm @ 4500 rpm||250 Nm @ 1500 – 2750 rpm|
|Transmission||6-Velocity MT / 6-Velocity AT||6-Velocity MT / 6-Velocity AT|
Okay then…. Let’s get to probably the most compact SUV of the lot. You get each petrol and diesel engine choices within the Hyundai Alcazar. It is is identical Creta sourced 1.5-litre, four-cylinder CRDi unit belting out 113 bhp at 4000 rpm and 250 Nm of peak torque between 1500 – 2750 rpm. he one with us is the petrol variant with a 2.0-litre, four-cylinder MPi motor below its hood. The petrol mill is comparatively a high-revving engine with 157 bhp at 6500 rpm and 191 nm of peak torque at 4500 rpm. Each engines can be found with both a six-speed guide or a six-speed torque-converter computerized gearbox.
To start with, the throttle response is sort of good. Though you are feeling a way of lag within the backside finish which is ok, which isn’t a deal breaker by any considered the creativeness. And when you speak in regards to the journey high quality, it’s plush, neither too stiff nor too delicate. It offers you the precise stability between each and when you speak in regards to the dealing with, sure the steering weighs fairly properly and when you examine it to the Creta I might say that the dealing with of the Creta and the Alcazar are roughly related. So it’s a comfy automobile to drive. It’s a comfy automobile to be in when you’re going for lengthy drives and sure, the top-end it’s barely missing nevertheless it’s alright. The underside is actually sturdy. It isn’t a tall SUV and that works in its favour relating to physique rolls. We are able to spend extra time on this automobile with out getting drained so caught in a site visitors jam for instance, shifting site visitors, and even on the freeway for lengthy rides. However you are not comfy within the third-row and we can’t choose this space to spend lengthy hours and for an extended journey. For youths within the household, most likely this house is good although the width remains to be tight.
|Mahindra XUV700||2.0-litre Petrol||2.2-litre Diesel MX||2.2-litre Diesel AX|
|Displacement||1997 cc||2184 cc||2184 cc|
|Max Energy||197 bhp @ 5000 rpm||153 bhp @ 3750 rpm||182 bhp @ 3500 rpm|
|Peak torque||380 Nm @ 1750-3000 RPM||360 Nm @ 1500 – 2800 rpm||420 Nm @ 1600 – 2800 rpm (MT) / 450 Nm @ 1750 – 2800 rpm (AT)|
|Transmission||6-Velocity MT / 6-Velocity AT||6-Velocity MT||6-Velocity MT / 6-Velocity AT|
And eventually we come to the most recent child on the block. So the Mahindra XUV700 too is obtainable each with petrol and diesel engine choices and the latter one- the two.2-litre, four-cylinder CRDi diesel is obtainable in three completely different states of tunes. Whereas within the base MX variant it may be revved extra however is a bit humble at 153 bhp and 360 Nm of peak torque and is obtainable with the six-speed guide as customary, within the AX guide trim it churns out 182 bhp at 3500 rpm and 420 Nm of peak torque at 1600-2800 rpm. The torque output goes as much as 450 Nm at 1750 – 2800 rpm when mated to the six-speed auto gearbox.
We have the two.0-litre, four-cylinder turbo petrol engine with us which has been fairly in demand. It belts out 197 bhp at 5000 rpm and 380 Nm of 1750 – 3000 rpm throughout variants and regardless of gearbox choices. And talking of the gearbox, even this one is offered both with a six-speed guide or a six-speed computerized. Now the petrol like the opposite two is obtainable with the front-wheel-drive setup as customary, whereas the diesel will get the all-wheel-drive (AWD) system as an possibility within the computerized iteration.
The brand new petrol mill is a is a quite peppy engine. The underside finish shove is sweet, the mid-range is actually sturdy when you’re driving this automobile within the metropolis or out on the highways happening an extended drive, you’ll take pleasure in this automobile and why I say so is as a result of we spent numerous time with this automobile as a result of once we drove the XUV700 to Ladakh to Umling La which is the very best motorable move on the face of this earth. The driving dynamics the dealing with of the automobile is maybe the perfect amongst the three SUVs that we’ve got right here at present. The automobile does not get out of form. The suggestions from the steering is very nice and even when you’re cornering laborious like we did on all these mountainous roads is feels very agile and keen. The XUV700 can also be giving the safari some robust competitors in respect to its journey high quality. You possibly can spend good time right here with out getting drained and on each dynamics smart and journey high quality smart the SUV Scores very extremely. Even within the third row when it comes to journey high quality and even dealing with if you end up making these lane adjustments, it is a lot sorted and I really feel it higher then each vehicles Alcazar and the Safari. Simply that I really feel fairly hemmed in due to tighter headroom and this brief window space if that may have been made higher.
So whereas the Hyundai Alcazar feels peppier and extra zippy to drive within the metropolis, on the freeway it feels a bit confused when revved to the purple. The Tata Safari alternatively is sort of the alternative! It feels in its aspect on the longer and open stretch, whereas in metropolis it feels a bit too cumbersome and cumbersome to chop by means of the site visitors and is not as tort with its physique manners. But it surely’s the Mahindra XUV700 with the precise stability. You do not really feel the size and bulk behind the wheel and it is fairly simple to drive within the metropolis. On the freeway at greater speeds it pleasantly surprises with its dealing with and physique manners whereas the journey too feels settled and never overly stiff.
Properly! Earlier than the ultimate reply, there’s one essential side that we at carandbike have been stressing for a very long time – ‘Security’. Just lately we learnt in regards to the XUV700 bagging a full 5-Star crash check ranking in grownup occupant security and 4-Star for little one occupant security by the GlobalNCAP and if you have not but, do take a look at our unique crash check report video at carandbike’s Youtube deal with. Now the Tata Safari and Hyundai Alcazar are but to be examined for security. However all three SUVs get extra then requisite security options like ABS with EBD, digital stability program (ESP) and Traction Management and likewise entrance, aspect and curtain airbags. The Mahindra XUV700 scores barely greater as its curtain airbags lengthen to the third-row as nicely!
|Fashions||Mahindra XUV700||Tata Safari||Hyundai Alcazar|
|Petrol||₹ 12.49 lakh – ₹ 21.29 lakh||NA||₹ 16.30 lakh – ₹ 20.00 lakh|
|Diesel||₹ 12.99 lakh – ₹ 22.99 lakh||₹ 14.99 lakh – ₹ 23.18 lakh||₹ 16.53 lakh – ₹ 20.15 lakh|
And eventually every thing boils right down to the costs. The Mahindra XUV700 undercuts each fashions on the base variant by over ₹ 2.5 lakh whereas solely the range-topping luxurious trims are round ₹ 1.5 lakh dearer than the equal Alcazar. The Tata Safari with all of the bells and whistles prices over a lakh greater than the fully-loaded AWD Mahindra XUV700. So with none second guessing, the Mahindra XUV700 has a giant edge being probably the most inexpensive of the lot and by fairly a margin, just about explains these overwhelming reserving numbers!
When it comes to look and design, the Tata Safari stands out. It has daring muscular attraction, a strong street presence and likewise the journey high quality of the Safari on damaged roads is actually actually good, and this automobile is actually spacious as nicely. The Alcazar actually scores greater when it comes to options and for an city purchaser this appears very fashionable, and clearly the compact dimensions assist in metropolis driving situations.
However it’s the XUV700 which actually takes on the nice qualities of each the Safari and Alcazar and builds on them. It’s a well-rounded package deal and relating to dynamics and efficiency it clearly takes the lead and that’s the reason on this unique comparability of ours the most recent automobile within the phase can also be the perfect automobile within the phase.
For the newest auto information and critiques, comply with carandbike.com on Twitter, Fb, and subscribe to our YouTube channel.